USGBC Panel Rejects ‘Blunt Instrument’ of Negative PVC Credit

April 16, 2007

Arlington, VA – The Vinyl Institute recently stated that the final report from a U.S. Green Building Council panel on PVC (vinyl) reaffirmed the conclusions of its earlier draft report; that PVC should not be the subject of a negative credit in the Council's LEED® rating system.

"This is the right decision," says Tim Burns, president of the Vinyl Institute.

The report by the Council's Technical and Scientific Advisory Committee (TSAC) stated that materials-related credits are a "blunt instrument" that could steer designers to choose materials with a more negative life-cycle impact. The draft report issued in December 2004 reached a similar conclusion.

The technical committee also found that data gaps frustrated its efforts to reach general conclusions about materials. While thousands of studies have been conducted on PVC, and its health and environmental profile is well established, the report recognized that there are major data gaps with respect to many competing materials.  

"The report of the committee was correct in stating that there are no simple 'yes' or 'no' answers to assessing the desirability of different building materials," adds Burns. "We agree with many of the recommendations of the technical committee relating to how materials are assessed in LEED. Specifically, we agree with the need for integrated methods for material evaluation rather than passing judgment on a particular credit for a particular material."

At the same time, Burns expressed strong concern that in some areas the committee appeared to have made assumptions and jumped to conclusions in cases where there was little or no data. This was especially evident in its comments on end-of-life issues, such as backyard burning and landfill fires, on which the committee acknowledged that its data was "highly uncertain."

"The fact is that landfill fires are extremely rare in the United States, and the burning of waste at construction sites is outlawed in most jurisdictions, so this is largely a non-issue," says Burns.

Founded in 1982 and located in Arlington, VA, the Vinyl Institute is a national, independent trade association representing leading manufacturers of vinyl plastics, as well as makers of vinyl feedstocks, additives, and film and sheet products. 

For more information about PVC's energy and environmental benefits, go to  or

Sponsored Recommendations

Two New Reports Offer Groundbreaking Guidance for Carbon and Material Health

Perkins&Will and Healthy Building Network launch resource for selecting products that champion both environmental and material safety, spotlighting a shift toward holistic sustainabilit...

The Durable Coated Fabrics Task Group’s Guide to Specifying Healthcare Materials

Here are the best questions to ask and what to prioritize in today’s post-pandemic world.

i+s Spotlights Those Giving Back for Thanksgiving

As Americans celebrate Thanksgiving tomorrow, we’re applauding some of our industry’s greatest charitable initiatives.

KOVA’s Dan Sullivan Talks Optimization for Adaptive Reuse

What makes a building a prime candidate? And what technology advances are streamlining the process? Sullivan answers all this and more. Read, then listen...

Voice your opinion!

To join the conversation, and become an exclusive member of I+S Design, create an account today!